Tag archives for mistakes

Violinmaking is a lot of fun for me but it is also a lot of tedious work. This week (and the next few to follow) covers a process that takes a lot of patience and can really mark the difference between a craftsman and an amateur maker. I’ve moved on to inlaying the purfling which requires very small cuts, chisels and fractions of millimeters to make. Purfling is best described as the black lines that outline the instrument. On most instruments they are inlayed and they act as both decorative and protect against cracks that form on the edge. This week I started cutting the channel to put the purfling into and I ran into a lot of difficulties again working with maple to spruce.
First, let me refresh where I was at the end of last week. The plates were glued together and there were very slight differences in the pattern that I evened out with a file.

Plates Glued to Make Semetrical

Corner Differences

After everything looked even and square, the plates were separated and Mr. Vartanian had me sand down the edge very flat so I could trace the purfling channel.

Flattening the Edge

Flat Edge

I then used a purfling tool which you can find pictured in the Tools section to trace the channel a certain distance in from the squared off edge. Any imperfections in the edge are displayed in the channel and may have to be fixed later on. Also, if the blades aren’t perpendicular or the tool isn’t pressed down enough to make a line, it is very difficult to go back and trace.

Tracing the Purfling Channel

Once the channel was traced, Mr. Belote let me use a sharp knife and a handmade chisel to cut the channel out. The knife is used to cut deeper into the traced line and make it easier to chisel out the wood.

Knife and Chisel Used

Closeup of Chisel

Thomas Cutting the Channel

As I mentioned earlier this is very tedious work. Even with the knife cuts, the wood doesn’t always come out of the grove very cleanly. In order for the purfling to lie nicely, the channel should be about 2.5mm deep and flat on the bottom. I finished the back and found out I was at most 2mm deep in spots and much shallower in most sections.

Channel cut on Back

I am also leaving the corners alone at this point. The purfling tool doesn’t help bring the channel to a point as is standard on most violins. The point where purfling pieces meet is called a bee-sting usually. In great violins this is very clean, follows very smooth lines, and is done all by hand and eye. Mr. Vartanian worked on two corners for me that I will be copying and cleaning. When looking at the craftsmanship of a violin, how much attention a maker puts into the corner and how well it’s done truly says a lot about their skill and probably the craftsmanship on the rest of the instrument. While this isn’t a guarantee it is a good place to start and will be interesting to see how mine end up.

Closeup of Corner

As I started working on the top a lot of problems started happening again. The direction of the grain causes bumps for the knife and even tracing the channel is difficult because the tool can get caught in a straight line and not curve around nicely. The other difficulty is how easy it is to split the grain and cause chips if one is not careful. For as slow as I went, it is not second nature to know how the knife is cutting the grove and a few chips occurred.

Top Grain Chipped Off

Chipped Grain

The first of these and a few others will disappear as I do more work but the second and a corner was glued just in case.

Chip Glued

Channels Cut on Both Plates

So my next task is going back over all the work I did which is what makes this part so frustrating in a way. But I am still having fun and for those of you who never know what those lines were on your instrument, I hope you now appreciate how they got there.

Read more about Cutting the Purfling Chan... »

I’ve decided to not hurt the corners anymore! You may remember three updates ago I split a corner of the back. Well, working on the top this past week, I cut a corner completely off by accident. I’ve mentioned before how different it is to deal with spruce compared to maple. Since the grain of spruce runs vertically, it is possible to catch that grain and in my case, go straight down it. Of course, it is possible to fix small mistakes like this but this goes to show how difficult it is to produce a violin.

When I worked on the back plate, I used files to bring the edge down where the bandsaw could only rough out. The same process is used for the top but Mr. Vartanian wanted me to be very exact in the corners and smoothly take out small humps with a knife. The pin/pencil line is very easy to see and it makes cutting and filing more exact. As I was cutting one of the corners, the knife caught a rough spot, I was pushing in the wrong direction and the knife made a clean cut.

Cutting the Edge with a Knife

Cutting Corners

Upper Left Corner Cut

Upon showing this to Mr. Vartanian and Mr. Belote they showed me that I was cutting and not slicing the wood. Slicing the wood involves dragging the blade while pulling it forward. I also needed to smooth the wood in the corners more with a file before using the knife. This way there would be fewer ridges that could catch the blade. I let Mr. Vartanian help me fix the corner by using a clamp I was unfamiliar with to glue it back on.

Corner Clamp

Corner Glued Back On

Corner Fixed

Due to the holiday I had less time to work and the corner delay only left me time to continue taking the edge down. When the top was closer (and all the corners nice and intact) I glued it very lightly to the back using only a few drops of hide glue. This is done to make sure both plates are completely symmetrical. Any differences in the edge I will be filing and slicing down before more precisely completing the arching and inlaying the purfling.

Gluing the Plates Together

Closeup of Plates Glued.

Read more about Cutting the Edge »

This has been an eventful week. Due to some things that I should have fixed earlier on, I’ve put myself behind a little and had to change my plans some as well. I continued roughing the arching down and found I was more successful going ahead and using a finger plane than the gouge from the previous week.

Back Plate with Finger Plane

Arching on the Back

Back Plate Arching

Now that my edge was thinner I started taking it down again to the pencil line with files and using my original template as a guide. At one point I was checking a few things with Mr. Belote and he went ahead and took the button down at the top of the plate as well.

Filing Down the Shape

End Button

At this point I decided that there were too many imperfections in my template and I had gone a little too narrow in the C-bout that I could no longer use it on the side I was working. An untraditional move, Mr. Belote helped me make a new template. We used a thick paper instead of the poster board and to save time, Mr. Belote cut out the template for me. When cutting out the pattern, you have to do it in one cut because lifting will cause inconsistencies in the pattern which I didn’t want to deal with again.

Tracing the New Template

Cutting the New Template

Cutting the Template View 2

The New Template

The reason I had to cut a new template was to trace it onto the other side. Since my pattern was based on the template from Henry Strobel’s book, I needed something new to make the side symmetrical. I want to take this time to apologize to Henry Strobel. The information in his book is quite helpful and in the right hands can produce an amazing instrument. A few poor decisions on my part led to what I have now and say nothing to the information he provides in his book.

I clamped and traced the pattern on the other side under supervision and started taking down to the line again. Even when the line is mostly gone that isn’t close enough. A fraction of a millimeter can make the entire side look lopsided. It was imperative I get the side down to just the pencil line.

The Pencil Trace

Pencil Line Left

Once I had the pencil line taken away I brought the plate to Mr. Vartanian for inspection. He was approving to say the least, though he could easily tell I had to cut some corners to get to where I was. He told Mr. Belote to help me take down the edge to four and a half millimeters with the drill press using a special circular saw. Mr. Belote took down the bulk of the edge to 5mm as I observed and took pictures. I then took a pass and took it down the rest of the way.

Drill Press Still

Drill Press Moving

Taking Down the Edge

Taking Down the Edge 2

Edge Taken Down

Closeup C Bout

Closeup Edge

Taking Away the Chips

A key to this quick trick is to keep pressure on the plate so that it doesn’t lift up as you slide it under the press. Twice I let up the pressure and the edge is a little thin in those spots. That’s something I’ll just have to live with at this point.

Now that the edge was flat, it made a lot easier to see and measure angles that Mr. Vartanian wanted to check. Most importantly he wanted to adjust the edge of the corners so they pointed a certain way. I started to file these down and then he showed me to take them down with a knife instead. As I took the second corner down the right angle I slipped and heard a crack. I split the wood!

Split Corner

Glued Corner

So, we glued it. In the end, this edge/crack will be rounded off so it’s nothing to worry about; it could have been a lot worse. It’s nice to see instruments made today that look perfect to the naked eye but they too may have had small mistakes like this happen.

A little more time was spent finalize the shape off the new template and other symmetrical measurements and I had to get the new pattern to the top wood. My corners were a little short compared to the template so another untraditional technique/idea was given to me by Mr. Belote. Usually, the template is used to trace the back and the top. Since both of mine are no longer the same as the end product I just clamped and trace the back directly to the top wood. I used a pin to trace the plate which is a trick used by Mr. Vartanian with his template.

Finished Back Shape

Back on Top Wood

Pin Used to Trace Shape

Back Clamped to the Top to Trace

Once the pin imprint is in the wood it can be traced with a pencil making it much easier to cut out and file down. Hopefully this will save me time and catch me up to getting the arching more complete over the next few weeks.

Read more about The New Template »